Types of touch screens
Translation of the original in Catalan. Read it in: CatalàCastellano
After working for quite a few years in the world of kiosks and digital signage, it had never crossed my mind to look into what the real differences are between the different types of touch screens on the market. So, finally, I decided to do it and to describe it in this article.
Resistive Touch Screen
- The technology with the best price-quality ratio of all touch technologies
- Available for screens from 5.7" up to 22"
- Made up of different layers:
- the most important ones are two thin layers: one metallic and the other made of layers that conduct electricity, these layers are very thin and are separated from each other by a very small gap
- when an object, a finger for example, presses the screen then the metallic layers touch and let the electricity through
- when there is a connection at that point, the screen acts as a voltage divider on the outputs that have the connection and they register the event, telling the controller that someone has touched the screen
- the technology is quite reliable, durable and usually has a long life span
- it is the most resistant technology in hostile environments
- it is cheap
- it is very stable, that is, it never or almost never needs recalibrating
- compatible with different kinds of touches: finger, stylus, pencil, etc.
- ideal for applications with heavy use
- can even withstand the NEMA 4/4x/12 and IP 65 standards
- if we look closely at the touch panel against the light we can even see the tiny filaments it is made of
- prone to scratches or cracks on the touch surface
Surface Acoustic Wave (SAW)
- its main virtue is its transparency
- sizes from 6.4" to 42"
- it uses ultrasonic waves that travel over the touch screen
- when the panel is touched a part of the waves is absorbed
- then it registers where the waves have been absorbed and tells the controller the point of the touch
- the touch surface can be damaged and it keeps working (scratches or broken glass)
- dirt on the touch surface can interfere with its operation
- touch panels of this type that are made of glass work better than the others
- what is more, that makes them more transparent
- they do not need calibrating more than once
- they can be used in any way: finger, gloves, stylus, etc.
Capacitive
- long lasting
- good price-quality ratio
- waterproof to rain and dirt
- sizes from 5.7" to 32"
- often made of glass
- they work through sensors that act as capacitors
- the walls of the capacitors on the horizontal and vertical axes overlap
- taking advantage of the fact that the human body conducts electricity, when the finger touches the surface of the sensor the electric field changes and there is a change in capacitance
- they work by proximity, you do not even have to touch the panel
- a technology with quite a lot of durability that is used in quite a few POS systems, industrial ones, public kiosks, etc.
- it is quite a lot more transparent than resistive technology
- it only works with contact from a finger, or with styli that are conductive
- they support multi-touch systems
- a hard layer in the glass provides resistance to wear
- quite resistant to dirt
- it works quite well when we have to drag elements in the interface
- it is considered to have a light transparency coefficient of ~91.5%
Infrared
- Ideal for hostile environments and outdoor applications
- Sizes from 8.4" to 17"
- it uses a grid of infrared emitters based on LEDs that are spread along the horizontal and vertical axes of the screen, plus some photosensors placed on the opposite sides from the emitters
- the idea is to create a grid of infrared rays and when they are cut we have the touch
- it is not used for portable devices, only for fixed installations
- it can be used with a finger, gloves, stylus, etc.
- it is stable, it does not need calibrating
- it does not have to work with thin surfaces, they can be rough
- they can easily be combined with anti-vandalism systems
- used in Ingress Protection (IP) and NEMA standards
- for a long
3M MicroTouchTM DST Touch System
- Very large touch surfaces
- sizes of 32", 40", 42" and 46"
- chemically treated glass
- no stylus is needed to use it, it works with any object or element that touches the screen
- fast response
- they are not too prone to dirt
- 3M Dispersive Signal Technology (DST): basically it allows calculating the reflection waves that are produced in the treated glass when there is a touch
- Fast, accurate and very reliable
- It puts up with cracks, scratches or even objects resting on the screen and it keeps working accurately on the interactions
- Ideal for multi-user applications
- Exceptional transparency